How we write our guides, and fix mistakes
Our guides explain personality and friendship research in plain English. This page says how we find the research, how we check what we say about it, and what to do if you spot a mistake.
Where the research comes from
Every source is a peer-reviewed paper that has a PubMed record or a DOI, and each one links straight to it from the guide's References. We look papers up in PubMed and Crossref, and we only cite one whose abstract (and, for any number we quote, the place it appears) we have opened ourselves. A search-engine snippet, a news story about a study or a memory of one is not enough. If we can't open it, we don't cite it.
Where there is a choice we prefer meta-analyses and large samples over a single small study.
How we check them
- Reference check. A script looks up every reference in PubMed or Crossref and compares its title, first author and year with what we cite. A reference that doesn't match is fixed or dropped before a guide ships, and a published guide may not carry an unverified reference. Small differences, such as a paper's print year versus its online-first year, are flagged for a person to look at.
- Claim check. A sentence that carries a citation may say only what that paper's abstract, or the full text we read, says: the same direction of effect, the same group of people, the same number, and correlation described as correlation, not as cause. Anything broader goes in our own words, hedged, with no citation.
- Fact-check passes. After writing, we audit published guides claim by claim against the cited papers. Our first passes found that a real share of claims (roughly one in ten to one in four in the first two) went further than the source supported. We fixed every one in place, and we kept the stricter rule above.
- Honest about mixed evidence. When studies disagree or a finding hasn't replicated well, the guide says so. We describe effect sizes in plain words instead of leaving them as bare numbers.
Figures without made-up data
A figure may say only what its guide's own checked text says. Most are simple pictures of an idea or a model, captioned as one, and they show no data. We don't draw a dot on a scale or size a box in a way that implies how many people fall where. A figure with numbers names the study they come from, right on the image. If we can't trace a label to the guide's text, the label is cut. The reuse terms are on their own page.
What the guides are not
The guides are not medical or mental-health advice, and they don't diagnose anyone or label people. They are published under the Guess My Vibe name rather than an individual author's, and none claims review by a named expert. We would add that only if it were true and verifiable. Who we are is on the about page.
Corrections
Found something wrong, out of date, or stated more strongly than its source? Email support@guessmyvibe.com with the guide's link, the sentence in question and, if you have it, the paper or page that shows the problem.
We re-read the cited paper, and if you are right we fix the guide. The date shown at the top of a guide as “updated” moves to the day it changed. If the source doesn't support a claim and we can't find one that does, the claim comes out. Corrections don't have to wait for a scheduled update.